Editorial: Fire Safety Regulations Fall Short; Common Sense Should Guide Combustible Placement Near Homes

In January, Southern California experienced a series of devastating wind-driven fires that swept through neighborhoods, fueled by embers from burning brush. The flames quickly engulfed homes, fences, and outdoor furniture, leading to widespread destruction. Fire scientists emphasize that proactive measures are crucial in fire prevention, underscoring the importance of creating defensible spaces around properties before fires ignite.

In response to the increasing threat of wildfires, the California Legislature passed Assembly Bill 3074 in late 2020. This legislation mandates that homes in high-risk fire zones establish a five-foot defensible space, known as Zone Zero, around them. While the state already requires a 100-foot clearance of brush and debris, this new regulation aims to enhance protection against embers that can travel long distances and ignite structures.

However, the implementation of this law has faced significant delays. The California Board of Forestry and Fire Protection, responsible for drafting the regulations for Zone Zero, has yet to finalize the rules, missing the January 2023 deadline by two years. Critics are questioning the slow progress, especially given the increasing intensity of wildfires in the region.

Christine McMorrow, a spokesperson for Cal Fire, acknowledged the board’s efforts to expedite the rule-making process but noted the complexities involved. The board aims to consider the financial implications for homeowners and is focused on developing an educational plan to help residents understand the importance of maintaining defensible space. The specifics of what materials and structures are permissible within Zone Zero remain under discussion, with questions about the use of wooden fences, deck materials, and window frame compositions still unresolved.

Despite the ongoing delays, Cal Fire has provided recommendations for homeowners looking to create their own defensible spaces. These guidelines advise against using combustible materials such as mulch, flammable furniture, and certain types of landscaping, suggesting alternatives like pavers, gravel, or concrete.

The board is expected to address the Zone Zero regulations in its upcoming March meeting, although a final decision may still be some time away. Governor Gavin Newsom has intervened, issuing an executive order on February 6 that instructs the board to draft rules and initiate public comment within 45 days, aiming for completion of the formal rule-making process by December 31. However, many believe this timeline is still too lengthy, particularly as rebuilding efforts in fire-affected areas are already underway.

Once the rules are established, they will apply first to new constructions, with existing properties required to retrofit within a few years. While the costs associated with implementing these regulations are expected to be lower than the expenses incurred from rebuilding homes destroyed by fire, the delay in enforcement raises concerns about the safety of neighborhoods vulnerable to wildfires.

Fire scientists emphasize that the effectiveness of these regulations extends beyond individual homes; a community-wide approach to defensible space can significantly enhance fire safety for entire neighborhoods. Although perfect adherence to Zone Zero guidelines may not eliminate the risk of fire, it can substantially increase the chances of homes surviving future embers and flames.

As the state continues to grapple with the implications of these regulations, local jurisdictions are encouraged to take action on their own. Some areas in California have already adopted Zone Zero rules, and cities like Los Angeles could follow suit to bolster fire safety measures.

Homeowners in fire-prone areas are urged to consider establishing defensible spaces around their properties, even in the absence of state regulations. Making sacrifices in landscaping and materials can provide crucial protection against the next inevitable wildfire, potentially saving homes and lives in the process.